277 - Fire Engineering in the Balkans with Tatjana Vasiljevic Vladev and Nikolin Risilia
Glass towers, deep basements, five-star hotels, airports, and mixed-use megaprojects are rising across the Balkans, and the fire risk is no different there than in London or New York. The difference is the system around the work: limited fire engineering education, uneven certification pathways, fragmented standards, and approvals that can drift into “checkbox compliance” instead of proving a working fire strategy.
From Venice, we talk with Tatjana Vasiljevic Vladev (SFPE North Macedonia) and Nikolin Risilia (SFPE Albania) about what actually happens on real projects. We dig into who is allowed to sign fire protection engineering documents, why “any engineer can do it” often translates into low competency, and how authorities and peer reviewers struggle when they can only validate isolated details rather than the full strategy. We also unpack the messy reality of code ecosystems: partial translations, legacy bylaws, mixing EN standards with NFPA and others, and what that means when insurers or international investors show up with their own requirements.
We then follow the building lifecycle: when fire safety enters the design process, why late involvement breaks architecture and building services, and how commissioning can become a simple “pipe, pump, checked” routine without testing performance. Finally, we talk solutions that can start now: involving firefighters earlier, building local capacity without technical colonization, and using SFPE chapters, conferences, and regional training to raise the baseline quickly.
If you work internationally or want to understand how fire safety engineering develops in fast-growing markets, hit play, share this with a colleague, and leave a review with the one change you think would make the biggest impact.
----
The Fire Science Show is produced by the Fire Science Media in collaboration with OFR Consultants. Thank you to the podcast sponsor for their continuous support towards our mission.
00:00 - Why The Balkans Matter Now
03:06 - Sponsor OFR Consultants
04:07 - Who Gets Licensed To Sign
12:55 - No Education Means Low Competency
23:25 - When Codes Do Not Fit Skyscrapers
25:59 - Fire Safety Arrives Too Late
37:19 - Commissioning Turns Into Checkboxing
44:30 - Firefighters Left Out Of Planning
51:50 - SFPE Chapters As A Fast Fix
01:00:20 - Europe’s Fire Education Bottleneck
01:03:50 - Final Takeaways And Thanks
Why The Balkans Matter Now
Wojciech WegrzynskiHello, everybody. Welcome to the Fire Science Show. Today, perhaps a little less science, but very much performance-based fire safety engineering episode. And actually, we're gonna talk about fire, how fire safety engineering is practiced. We know a lot about how it's practiced in the UK, in the US, and you know, in the countries from which we all gather our experiences and, uh, where this is a very matured craft, let's say. But, this is practiced all over the world, and I personally, coming from Poland, I can relate to perhaps new players on the market, countries which are now adopting or introducing fire safety engineering into their law systems, into their engineering practice, and they meet a lot of struggles, uh, doing that. And it's interesting to learn how those struggles look like and how the solutions to those struggles look like, because this is something that perhaps can be implemented elsewhere, in a wider way. In this podcast episode, I will take you to a beautiful part of, uh, Europe, which is the Balkans, and, um, I will personally represent Eastern Europe, I guess. Uh, with me today are two fantastic leaders from our core group at SFP Europe, that is Tatjana Vasiljevic Vladev from SFP North Macedonia, and Nikolin Risilia from SFP Albania. And, uh, together we cover a lot of challenges, actually. Three countries, three different looks on fire safety engineering practice, three different sets of, uh, of challenges And very interestingly, you know, uh, s- things that are perhaps on the main agenda in the UK like, uh, certification, we all have it kind of, and we don't have great education, for example, and perhaps importing projects here is a little bit difficult or maybe mixing the standardization ecosystem is difficult, and the role of firefighters differentiates. A l- a lot of differences even though we are geographically so close. And, uh, yeah, I can also say that, the way how those countries in the Balkans are growing, uh, the amount of business opportunities, their investments, magnificent major projects happening right now are happening is insane. And, uh, there's a very good chance that even if you work in your office in London, you will end up working on a project in Albania. And if you do that, you better know how it looks like in there. So, enough of me rambling around in here. Please join me and my great friends from SFP Europe to see how the world of fire protection engineering looks like in Balkans and in Eastern Europe. Let's spin the intro and jump to the episode.
Sponsor OFR Consultants
Wojciech WegrzynskiThe Fire Science Show podcast is brought to you in collaboration with OFR Consultants, a multi-award-winning independent consultancy dedicated to addressing fire safety challenges. OFR is the UK's leading fire risk consultancy that this year celebrates its 10th anniversary. As experts in fire engineering, they are fully committed to delivering preeminent expertise to protect people, property, and the environment. With over 30 chartered engineers and a team of fire researchers at their core, they continually explore the challenges that fire creates for their clients and society so that the best research, experience, and diligence can be applied for effective tailored solutions. In 2026, OFR will grow its team once again and is keen to hear from industry professionals who want to collaborate on fire safety features this year. Get in touch at ofrconsultants.com. And now back to the episode
Who Gets Licensed To Sign
Wojciech WegrzynskiHello, everybody. I am joined today in beautiful Venice, uh, with, uh, two colleagues, uh, who are leader of their SFPE chapters. Uh, Tatjana Vaskevski Vlade from North Macedonia. Hey, Tatjana.
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevHi.
Wojciech WegrzynskiAnd Nikolin Rislia from, uh, Albania chapter. Hello. Hi, everybody. And, uh, together we're representing, let's say, new kids on the block, eastern part of the Europe, southern part of the Europe. But, uh, generally countries, uh, which perhaps a lot of people would not connect with, uh, you know, the mainstream fire safety engineering. But we have to do fire safety engineering in our countries. The risk of fire is the same everywhere. And, I think it could be an interesting perspective for, colleagues around the world, and especially colleagues in the countries which have established fire engineering for decades- on how does it look like and what, what kind of, difficulties we find. Let's start with, uh, with the practice of fire protection engineering. So h- how in general fire safety is practiced in North Macedonia, Tatjana?
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevSo generally, uh, our country is regulated through the Chamber of Architects Engineers, or there is an official certification who is given by this department with this, uh, fire protection prot- department. The people who can apply in this department are for, Entities who are doing architectural or engineers, architectural engineers, uh, civil engineers, mechanical, electrical engineers, they need to fulfill a few, steps. So they need to have degree, uh, if you want an A type of buildings to apply, and two years of experience. And i- if you want to have, uh, that's the B, and if you need to have, A license, which are government buildings, hospitals or heritage buildings So you need to apply with a master degree as an engineer and then five years of experience. But,
Wojciech Wegrzynskibut, but is this for, for fire specific or all construction kind of stuff?
Tatjana Vasiljevic Vladevthis chamber it's l- related to certification of every kind of engineering that is doing, something related to construction and buildings. So you have certification for architects, certification for electrical, mechanical, civil engineer, and then you have this department which is called Fire Protection Department- Okay where you applying related to fire.
Wojciech WegrzynskiOkay. And-
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevSo there is a specific certificate that is covering all the elaborates or documents- Okay. So- that you are submitting
Wojciech Wegrzynskithat's really interesting because you actually have some kind of credency, uh, scheme in your country. And, and do you have education for that?
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevNo, no. Official education, no. So your, uh, education comes from a training or, if you're educated out of the country related to master degree, so that's the, the kind of education that you can get.
Wojciech WegrzynskiN- Nikolaj, in Albania, how, how does the landscape look like?
Nikolin RisiliaUh, let's say that is, the same with North Macedonia and even I think other Balkan countries. We don't- doesn't have any training, professional training or academics and curricula for fire engineering. we have a certification that is for fire expert that could be- Mm any kind of engineer or architect and can do this, this profession. But, uh, we are talking here about the passive fire protection. But, uh, if you go to active fire protection, you need to have a license that give us from Ministry of Public Works, the, or Transport as it's called, and this is a license for this discipline of engineering. And, some disciplines, for example, hydraulic engineer, mechanical engineer, or electric engineer even have one point that is, uh, fire protection of system, electrical system, uh, hydraulic system, water-based system, et cetera, for evacuation, smoke evacuation, et cetera. So that in terms who is something that, is without any education, without any continuous training, and somehow is the level of professional is very low.
Wojciech WegrzynskiI, I'll give you an example of how it looks in Poland, if you're interested. In Poland, We have a education actually because we have, the main school of fire service. It was c- called in the past, now it's called Fire Academy. It's a technical university that trains, um, officers for fire brigade. And it also has a full kind of fire protection engineering course. So actually, every single fire officer is a fire protection engineer at the same... Be- they had to go through the course like that and that also has a civilian department which, people leaving are fire protection engineers. And with that degree, you're allowed to do some s- let's say lower level, fire protection jobs like, choosing where the evacuation signs go, you know. Choosing where the f- portable fire equipment goes, writing some specific building documents, et cetera. But that does not give you power to approve design. For that, you have to go through a governmental kind of exam. So it's not a scheme where you, you study or, or whatever. There's no course for that. You have to pass the exam, and then you're given the right to approve designs and take liability for them, but that's for high-level design approval. And then there's everything in the middle, like CFD modeling, evacuation modeling for, for which like no credential... Like nothing exists. Anyone could do it. So we kind of have the education, we kind of have the credential system, but it doesn't mean that ev- competency of every person involved is, is checked or guaranteed. Neither of them is, is true. And, uh, what's interesting about your countries is that you already have the, some sort of legal requirements towards who can practice stuff, but, uh, h-how can you have competent people if you don't have an education? Where, where do you find your fire protection engineers?
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevSo how the thing starts, so we have a law that is part from Yugoslavia that was the former re- uh, republic, which was part Serbia, Croatia, um, Slovenia, and so on. And this legislation is from then. And in that period, there was acknowledgement, related to fire, and the older generation learned from that. But during the, the years and changing of generation, this area, like, not died, but the people with, knowledgement are already retired. Okay. So you have new generation now. How they are doing? They are doing by going to trainings. But again, we have not a lot of them around the country, so you struggle- Yeah, but, but
Wojciech Wegrzynskiinsides, not what's... You have to send them outside
Tatjana Vasiljevic Vladevyou have to, but you need to, need to push the, the companies to do that. Okay. And what is the, the main trouble? When you have a dedicated education, you're talking engineer to engineer on the same topic on a same level. Yeah. So you're discussing only if it's slightly more gray or a darker gray. In this situation as ours, you're talking another side, someone who don't have experience. Uh-huh. Have the license because somehow he jumped in the project, and then you're talking if it's gray or white-
Wojciech WegrzynskiOkay
Tatjana Vasiljevic Vladevor it's black.
Wojciech WegrzynskiLike w- with no level of understanding of
Tatjana Vasiljevic Vladeveach other. That's, that's the thing. That's the thing. So you're discussing about, sprinklers on fire compartments or whatever, which you cannot align to each other. You cannot discuss it. It's, it's like a separate thing.
Wojciech WegrzynskiMm.
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevSo, how it's regulated in somehow in our country, every, uh, type of engineer who gets the, the certificate, uh, do their job. And, in the end, in the whole project, which is fire elaborate, they're putting everything together, not always, complementary one to another, so everybody doing separately- Mm their job, and in the end, someone is signing this. And in front of the municipal, it is submitted, and the level of knowledgement of the authority having jurisdiction pretty much low.
Wojciech WegrzynskiYeah. And Nikolin, for you, uh, how does the discussion with the authorities look like? Same, same issues? Uh, okay, d- don't say anything that can get you in trouble.
Nikolin RisiliaNo problem for me. I'm used to. Uh, idea is that, as I said, that, uh, you don't have training, you don't have academics, you don't have a curricula. In other hand, you even don't have, people or engineers that are specialized in their profession for fire. For example, I'm taking consideration electrical engineer for fire ala- alarm stuff. Mm-hmm. Because, uh, it's not, the same to do some electrical engineering- Yes and to do some fire alarm. Of course. Or s- smoke, management, and, uh, stair pressurization for a mechanical engineer. Needs some know-how and good know-how to, to do that. And in other hand, what is the problem? Problem is that, we go to send a permission to the minister, to, to a general directorate of, of fire and, uh, rescue in Albania, and you have to send this permission, based on passive fire protection. We don't have a code And, uh, we have some, let's say laws or from government that, until the, August have been Italian old law for residential building and the version translated in Albania of British standard to, uh, BS 9999:2008.
No Education Means Low Competency
Nikolin RisiliaOkay. And now for the moment, we have only that in order, and people struggling because some understand, some don't want to understand which contain this, law, let's say. And so there's a mess in the part of how to base these perspective laws. Performance-based design is not allowed to us.
Wojciech WegrzynskiNot allowed?
Nikolin RisiliaNot, because we have a perspective law, and nobody ask for something extra to do.
Wojciech WegrzynskiWow. So that, that's interesting. In, in my case, in Poland, in, in general, this perspective is, is-- Before I, I go to Poland, th- th- in general, this perspective is, I think, very, very interesting because I think a lot of countries like ours end up with a mix of codes, you know? Mm. Someone like the piece-- In Poland, someone like the piece of German code, someone like the B- British code. There's, um- Pressurization there's a little-- For, for some reason, pressurization is done on the French code, and no one understands why- but someone translated the code from French in, in 1990s, and here we are, you know? So, It's not granted that th- those systems are coherent. Like, if I look at the ecosystems like NFPA, they make a lot of sense when you apply everything from the NFPA ecosystem as a complete, you know, combination of codes and standards that make a sense. But where you cherry-pick a little, uh, little bits, uh, every now and then, it, it becomes, uh, a little bit problematic. Now, uh, the, the interesting part that you mentioned about the performance-based, design. In Poland, we have full performance-based design for smoke control. That's, that's really nice. Uh, but for other things it's prescriptive, but you obviously cannot design an airport or, you know, a skyscraper down to the code. So we have a painful process of derogations. You can apply to do something differently that the codes say, under the premise that you prove that this is, you know, good, and it's up to your fire safety engineer to provide that proof. This, um, measure like that... H- how-- You do a lot of skyscrapers. How do you do the skyscrapers and the lack of regulations?
Nikolin RisiliaYeah, this is challenge too because, uh, everything remains in hand of somebody that, is the taking care of this job. Somebody may have some consultation from outside-
Wojciech WegrzynskiMm
Nikolin Risiliafrom people that know, like I do- Yeah regularly with friends all around Europe or in States, that I ask for what I have to do for such, uh- Mm buildings, such, et cetera. For example, I'm trying to do, for example, some, airport to try to make with, Gabriele to, to make a performance-based design for this because it's impossible to follow the rules- Mm because it's growing every day.
Wojciech WegrzynskiBut, but, but how are you allowed to do that?
Nikolin RisiliaThis is the point, that I don't know that.
Wojciech WegrzynskiYou don't
Nikolin Risiliaknow? But I don't know. But I have to propose this because I see this is something that has stuck, and nobody can- Mm. Okay go even more. You know, British Standard doesn't allow you to go more than 50 meters.
Wojciech WegrzynskiYeah, yeah,
Nikolin Risiliayeah. And we have everything in country is over 50 meters.
Wojciech Wegrzynskiso basically you base it on the premise currently that, uh, you, you reached a wall and there is absolutely no way you can do it. What to do. So, so the option is not do at all or, do it, in a PBD way and see what happens.
Nikolin RisiliaUh, Tatiana was with me in Tirana, a fire safety conference that we had in Tirana, and my main topic was To, to be able to achieve a code for the country, not to create one- Yeah, yeah because impossible for our countries to make something like that. At least to find a code that is, appropriate for Albania
Wojciech Wegrzynskiand- The closest one
Nikolin Risiliathe closest one. Uh, and to apply this, and after that, to start to trainings or academies, curricula, whatever. We're working with private university, with state university to find a way to have the possibility to create a group of, performance-based design-
Wojciech WegrzynskiMm-hmm
Nikolin Risiliaengineers. And for this, it's not something you can do in one week or in six months- No, no, no, no you know very well. Yes, absolutely. So that's to start today and to achieve something in two years or three years.
Wojciech WegrzynskiYeah. It is an interesting struggle. I, I, I like the concept of, of just, you know, doing the good thing in the lack of, of regulation. Tatiana, if you would like to do per- performance-based fire safety engineering design-
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevSo I'll, I'll go back a little bit. So in our country it's a little bit different. You cannot, uh, design according that you want because there is an Institute of Standardization the engineers are not familiar with that, that the country, according to the directive, must apply the European norms officially and adapt it to their country. To assimilate or to take another country code or standard, you need to ask officially the Institute of Standardization. Mm-hmm. So they officially ask the country if this country can give this standard, and the only case that the institute is applying if there is no valid European standard. So that's the official thing to every institute in Europe who has this institution of standardization, who is accepting the CEN, the c- uh, Committee of European Norms, or ISO standards in their country. So pretty much it's clear. Uh, generally the whole project performance-based are, thing that, uh, it's not done in our country or it's really hard to explain it because of the low knowledgement. Most of them, everything that is done, it is done according to the standards, and they are struggling. Honestly, when the engineer cannot find the path, it's really hard to find the way how to do the project by the standards performance-based usually it's not an option, as I told you. It's, it's something that, uh, you need to have enough knowledgement in your country to someone take a look because at so- in some cases or some presentation Gabriela wants tell, um, was, was explaining garbage in, garbage out. Yes. So if there is a wrong design from the beginning, will be wrong till the end. Uh-huh. And if don't have an institution or, or a committee, or someone can, check your design, approve it, or you have a discussion about it, you cannot do performance. Then it's better to put prescriptive design by the standard. Then you know then in this situation you're on the safe side- Mm because someone covers your back in case of trial. Right. That's the main thing. The responsibility is the big thing that you need to sign in the end.
Wojciech WegrzynskiOkay, but now, okay, our countries are growing. Uh, there's a huge economical shift in, in our countries. I hope that's the true for, for your countries as well. It's definitely true for Poland. And, we start to have more ambitious architecture, bigger buildings. Uh, we have, uh, foreign investors, Western money, as we like to call it, coming into the country with, uh, big, companies behind it, and they now have to, uh, uh, deal with that. Uh, so the... Is this something that triggers a shift in the culture? having been exposed to, the engineering that comes from other countries which have more matured system than our countries. I think it could be something especially, uh, for you, Nikolin, because
Nikolin Risiliathis is true. It's what I say when we talk about fire and even performance-based design that a lot of my friends And contributors to SFP are afraid because they know very well that what word is performance-based design, what kind of engineering asks. Yeah. And, uh, so that they are... They're right to say that it's a very big challenge for us. But in other end, we are constructing the same that is constructing in Dubai, United States, even in Poland, and we are started from 25 to 80 floors above ground. And even- That
Wojciech Wegrzynskiis like 100 meters, 70 meters.
Nikolin RisiliaYes, it's always. Yeah. 200 meters, 300 meters- Okay around. And you have even 20, 25 meters underground.
Wojciech WegrzynskiOkay.
Nikolin RisiliaSo that it's not anymore a issue only to have some perspective laws- Mm-hmm because we don't even have a code that- Yeah covers everything. Yeah. So that we propose, like SFP, at least to have a code to cover everything And after that, if you want to go more because it's a request from architects from what they do that you to go further in performance-based design, let, let's start with some specialized guy from outside, outsource, then can do it and step by step to think about academic curricula, et cetera, whatever is possible to create a base with some people from the country, even from North Macedonia, even from Kosovo maybe that start performance-based design because it's the market that is requesting this professionality level. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. And so that where we are talking about the same level of construction and level of professional in our countries at, at least at mine is very low. What we have to do? We have to think about something fast and, and today, not for after 10 years.
Wojciech WegrzynskiBut, but, but you also don't want this kind of, uh, technical colonization kind of, uh, environment where like y- you need to build your own competency, your own people to be able to do that because you cannot really rely on external forces, especially that if you have consultants from UK, they will be familiar with the British, uh- Yes uh, environment. If you have firms from the US- Yes they will be IBC or NFPA oriented. Uh, uh, if you have German, Polish, whatever- Yes they will all come with some kind of preconception of what fire engineering is from their region, not necessarily compatible with your idea of what it is.
Nikolin RisiliaWe had, uh, we had, uh, during the conference, Tirana Fire Safety, we had a small table with Bjorn, Luciano Nigro-
Wojciech WegrzynskiOkay
Nikolin RisiliaCancelliere, and, uh, Rory from Arup, uh, is director of Ireland Arup, and we discussed this, uh, about what we have to do now in this phase that we, uh, don't have a real code. Mm-hmm. We have some British that is translated, 10 years before, 11 years before, but it's not complete. It's some parts of it.
Wojciech WegrzynskiMm-hmm.
Nikolin RisiliaAnd how to, to change the transition phase, what-- how to think in this phase transition that we have a lot of permission that's still to, to get the permission, high-rise building, five-star hotels, mixed public buildings, schools, hospitals, et cetera. And in other hand, what we have to do in near future, in one or two years about perspective, laws. And after that, to go to performance, we don't need only outsource for the future. We need outsource maybe for today because today we're not able to, to do this in right way, and this could be a problem. Mm-hmm. If you, if you get to take everybody in hand to do some performance-based design without any knowledge- Could be a mess worse than you to have a perspective, uh, code.
Wojciech WegrzynskiYeah, yeah,
Nikolin Risiliayeah. It's much simple to have a table with true
When Codes Do Not Fit Skyscrapers
Nikolin Risiliatwo or three things that you have to
Wojciech Wegrzynskido. Yes, but again, y- you're talking about architecture in which is impossible to tabularize it. Uh, Tatiana, for, for you, i- if you were allowed to do performance-based engineering, could some external consultants practice it in, in, in North Macedonia? Like, how does it look like?
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevSo officially not, so they cannot sign the papers. For signing the pa- papers, whatever, foreigner can apply in the Chamber of Architects and Engineers there for a license or for a certificate, but, if by... They own without this certificate, they cannot sign the paper. Mm. So they need a local, uh, someone who will sign the papers.
Wojciech WegrzynskiA translator kind of,
Tatjana Vasiljevic Vladevor- Translator or someone who will trust the whole project, will have the knowledgement, and will agree- Yeah to sign it at the end.
Wojciech WegrzynskiYeah, by, by translator, I mean someone who translates the engineering into the local context, not just the words, you
Tatjana Vasiljevic Vladevknow? Uh, yeah. That's the- That would be- there's a tricky part. Uh, compared to, to Albania, we have by law- Mm we have, a regulator area. The discussion is what is inside Because it's restricted, cannot comply with the new materials or new, the new structure way. But if you, uh, dig inside and take a look, it's, mentioned that you can design according to standards. Okay. EN standards, NFPA standards, ISO standards, so you can use them. Generally, you can use them, but what is the thing? The mixing of standards is also another issue. Someone, as you mentioned, they will do it NFP, I don't know, one area, and then other thing will be EN, and then other thing will be VDS or whatever- Yeah, yeah standard it's preferable.
Wojciech WegrzynskiIt's a massive problem in, in my country, the, the mixing of standards- Yeah really.
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevAnd the thing what I always, uh, discussing with the European colleagues, what do you think about NFP? NFP never can comply, for example, 5000 with Euro codes.
Wojciech WegrzynskiOkay.
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevIt's not compatible at all. There is a trick. Because according to law, you need to be according to European codes. You cannot use NFP 5000. We have a project where the request of the insurance, because the company was United States based, they requested to be according to NFP. Okay, we can build all the elements or designing the smoke extraction, fire detection- Mm fire suppression, and everything according to NFP, but the structural element was really hard to design it according to NFP 5000.
Wojciech WegrzynskiUh, that's, that is very interesting.
Fire Safety Arrives Too Late
Wojciech WegrzynskiUh, I w- I would like to move the discussion to the design process, so the steps it takes to, to get the building from the drawings to a construction and open to public. I wonder, um, how the steps look like in your countries, because again, it's, it's very different in different parts of the world where specific things are accepted, allowed. Like, how many stages do you have even? So maybe you can walk me through, through the process in, in North Macedonia.
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevYeah. So, so basically how it starts- you get the project and the leader of the project always is the architect. So he took the project, make some base design, and then he involve all the parties. So here is a civil engineer for the structural, here is the mechanical, electrical engineer, and mainly the fire engineer. What is the tricky part? Everything is doing their job, and the fire engineer enters at the end of the project.
Wojciech WegrzynskiOkay. But, okay, but At what level of technical detail does the project leave the architect's office for some sort of approval? Concept- On
Tatjana Vasiljevic Vladevthe big, uh... Okay, for the si- for, for the first approval, concept design.
Wojciech WegrzynskiConcept design.
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevOr basic design.
Wojciech WegrzynskiAnd then- And at that stage you don't have fire engineer on board?
Tatjana Vasiljevic Vladevmaybe only for advice. Okay. But a full elaborate, no. Okay. For the concept, no. Then later on when you go to the detail design, you're entering with the fire engineer, where is the last ph- phase of the whole procedure. That's the wrong thing. So you already finish everything, establish everything, consult with the investor, and now you're jumping, "Okay, we need the pressurization of the staircase." Okay. Yeah. And everybody, "Well, there is no space for it." That's mess. Or, "We need sprinkler now." "Oh, lower the ceiling," or whatever you need. Now the architectural design a total mess. And that's the thing that goes wrong. After finishing everything, you are applying in the municipality, where the agency which is responsible for this area give you the positive feedback, and after that the municipality give you the full permit that it's accepted the project. And you can start building. And you can start the building.
Wojciech WegrzynskiAnd, and then, uh, when you're building, do you have to do another round of the design, like technical design?
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevNo, the supervision have the role so they can follow the bas- the, the- Okay detail design. If there is a change or need of change, they need to inform the general designer that there will be a change of this area, what is their thoughts about it. Okay. And then they're jumping with the change if it's necessary.
Wojciech WegrzynskiBecause, you know, uh, a lot of buildings fail. They may be really well designed at the design stage, but in execution- Yes someone substitutes a material, a system or something, and if there's no process to, to cross-check that change and the impact of it, you can end up in a very-
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevHappens, happens. It's our country as well. Yeah. Depending of the investor, depending of the group of the designers. You know, in every country there is a level. So you have designer and designer, depending for, of the price, uh, depending of how, uh, experienced they, they, they are. So, so a lot of things.
Wojciech WegrzynskiNikolyn, for you, the process itself, uh, how, how does it look?
Nikolin RisiliaOkay. At us, those, uh, five year, last years have a bit different because we have a lot of, uh, international famous architects that works in country. Okay. And somehow, maybe it's a mess in some- Mm aspects of fire because some of them comes with British standard, some with NFPA in mind, but at least they find a person in the country that have to do the, the fire as it is locally.
Wojciech WegrzynskiMm-hmm.
Nikolin RisiliaAnd normally we start from that concept design. That is a good thing for us. And what is, uh, I seen in market in those years have been that, uh, fire is, uh, awareness is grow up very fast.
Wojciech WegrzynskiOkay.
Nikolin RisiliaWe have lack of professionals, but not of awareness for the fire.
Wojciech WegrzynskiAll right.
Nikolin RisiliaAnd this is a good thing in, in somehow, but have, uh, weak points because, uh, if you, push the people to do some fire and they, they are not professional, could be, uh-
Wojciech WegrzynskiDisaster
Nikolin Risiliadisaster. Yeah.
Wojciech WegrzynskiBut, but, but, but, but already at the concept stage you would be thinking about fire safety?
Nikolin RisiliaYes. Okay. For example, what is main point is, uh, two staircases.
Wojciech WegrzynskiOkay.
Nikolin RisiliaThat is, uh, the biggest one. And after that, the shafts, big shaft for pressurization, for smoke evacuation, uh, et cetera. And, technical, uh, floors in, uh- Mm upper floors, et cetera. Those are main issues that we are from because even, uh, the part of structural guy ask you to, to give some data to follow up with, uh, with permission. Because when you go for the permission, you have to send the, the papers to the directory of the fire and rescue to take permission from them. And after that to go to the, to the institute or to the faculty to make the check- Mm peer review of the, the design.
Wojciech WegrzynskiOkay.
Nikolin RisiliaAnd those goes, uh, m- mainly fire and structural thing.
Wojciech WegrzynskiWait, but who's doing the peer review? Because y- in general is, we, we concluded that there's lack of competency, so
Nikolin Risiliad- This is another point. This- Uh is a problem because that goes, just in general. Okay. They make some structural, things that is safe or not about the Euro code, et cetera. And the fire, they follow up, uh, with this, uh, the active part, uh, fire sprinkler, et cetera, et cetera. Okay. And people usually put that, uh, this is by EN 12845, everything is follow up like that. We have, uh, designed some sprinkler three meters, et cetera. Okay. Just,
Wojciech Wegrzynskijust claim that, not prove it.
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevSo the same thing, or maybe not the same in, in Macedonia, the revision is a little bit more on higher level related to they're looking what is by the bylaw. They follow up depending of the category of the building. So you have different category, industrial, warehouses- Mm-hmm public and so on. So they follow up. They, they can read this. But in related to the design, depending what is the type of reviewer that you have, maybe you will have an architect, then he can complain a- about the, the f- fire zoning or the the wide of the egress path. If a structural engineer, he can complain related to the resistance of the construction. But the s- structural engineer never complaining about the fire detection. Okay. Maybe it's wrong- Mm but nobody will knows.
Wojciech Wegrzynskiit's an interesting problem for, for me, if you put a Like, if you put a non-fire professional who does not understand the complexity of fire, uh, safe design and the fact that you may want those doors closed because of smoke control and open because of evacuation at the same time, and those are competing objectives. But a very stupid case, but it could be a case, you know? Yes. Yeah. A- and, uh, another person could tell you, "No, but this is the end of my fire compartment. This is a fire-rated door. They need to be closed." A person who has no fire safety engineering background can only verify it, "Okay, the requirement says R30, the doors is R30, it is good." Yes. That's the, that's the level- Yes you can check.
Nikolin RisiliaYes.
Wojciech WegrzynskiBut you cannot understand
Nikolin Risiliathe strategy- Yes and- This is the point.
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevSo the s- the strategy is missing here. everybody is applying according to bylaw or by the standard everything, materials by... in the, in the documents. But in the end, everything need to be function under one scenario. So everybody is struggling with the scenario. What is the scenario? Mm. Why you, you have compartmentation? How you will evacuate? You will evacuate the full building or you will evacuate only two st- stores above, below? What is the strategy? That's the thing that is the last thing at the project, and it's missing. Mm. So the cherry at the top of the cake, it's missing.
Nikolin RisiliaYeah.
Wojciech WegrzynskiNikolai, we, we interrupted you. You didn't reach the opening the building yet. So what happens between this, uh- Ah peer review and the- This is
Nikolin Risiliathe beautiful thing. Uh, I want to discuss- Yeah because I see this every day, and I struggle with that- Yeah because, uh, somehow some interested guy that are investors listen to you because they say, "I want everything safe for the fire because I have a hotel," for example, "five-star hotel. I have to run this for my life." Somebody is known in construction industry and he wants to construct for 100 years more. He want that his residential building to be good-
Wojciech WegrzynskiMm-hmm
Nikolin Risiliaand to apply every standard. Happens that you find those people, but everything is in desire of everybody.
Wojciech WegrzynskiYeah, yeah.
Nikolin RisiliaSo that control is not professional because authorities doesn't have, engineers to make the control. You don't have a education, you don't have nothing that people to understand what is happens with this system. For example, I can give you a very nice example to say. Uh, years before I start something that, uh, authority ask for sprinkler in every underground, uh, parking. But in Tirana, every building have underground parking, minus one, minus two, minus three. Yes, yes. And this is very normal. And you see that every parking have a system of sprinklers, but have some pipes, some, sprinkler heads, and maybe it's a pump that run the water for sanitary, or maybe it's a dedicated pump for water, For firefighter. And nobody control, nobody knows the system, nobody check. Mm-hmm. Because the, what makes authority just sign that you have the system-
Wojciech WegrzynskiMm-hmm
Nikolin Risiliais the same that they use with, uh, stand pipes- Mm with hydrants, et cetera. So that you have the system may be more installed in every country of, in the Balkan, that Albania have in every building, even the upper floor if you have some commercial. Uh, warehouses is low, hold low to 2007. Let's say every warehouse that is more than 250 meters have to have the, sprinkler on. So that even you make a small warehouse in a village to, to take a permission, you have to put some sprinkler.
Wojciech WegrzynskiBut they don't say what kind of sprinklers, what's-
Nikolin RisiliaNo, no, no, no, no, no, no. Nothing.
Wojciech WegrzynskiOkay.
Nikolin RisiliaJust, just that. And this is the idea. And now, with the law that we have, that is British 2008, they said that AN is right that every building over 30 meters cannot accept it without sprinkler.
Wojciech WegrzynskiMm-hmm.
Nikolin RisiliaAnd this is crazy too, because it's a standard that we applied now fully because the authority asked for him. but it's not complete. It's something, the only thing that we have now for the buildings, and they say, "I want sprinkler for building over 30 meters." And it's a mess of that. It's a mess without a code, without rules or laws that are write in fully
Wojciech WegrzynskiI mean, and this is also something to consider to colleagues who write those codes, in many parts of the world. Those solutions kind of propagate across the world. It's not that of course you're taking responsibility for your own country and it's hard to bless British colleagues for a mess, uh, in our, uh, parts of the world. But, you know, it's, it's kind- th- those solutions kind of propagate and, they propagate without the fundamental context of it. Like in British you'd have the fundamental, uh, functional- Yes requirements towards the buildings and I'm not sure if this is res- e- expected at the same level in your place and you may have a different requirements. If the code says sprinklers, it means sprinklers in con- in particular context of a standard that defines how they should be applied. But someone reading that in a different country can say- "Okay, sprinklers, one unit please." And they just install- Yes, yes one unit of sprinklers- without considering, uh, this. Um, when
Commissioning Turns Into Checkboxing
Wojciech Wegrzynskiyou want to... Okay, let, let's say you have approved design, uh, it went to the peer reviews- Yes you went through the construction period. What does happen at commissioning the building? Like do they just- Okay open it? Does someone check it, uh, Nikolin?
Nikolin RisiliaIn best scenarios they pick a detailed design from, from the studios that, uh... or engineer that makes the design for other aspects of engineering and they start to make the offers and to start to work. They find some, uh, companies- Yeah subcontractors that make this job. Some of them are good, knows sprinkler system, et cetera, let's say.
Wojciech WegrzynskiOkay.
Nikolin RisiliaLet's talk about that or, I don't know, smoke, et cetera. But nobody is able to certify to tell that this system is by the rules.
Wojciech WegrzynskiYeah, but the... Okay, but this construction and, and after you construct the building is finished, you want to open it, you just open it or the go- No the government
Nikolin Risiliacome- Like when it comes to you, I say that, "Is sprinkler?" "Yes." "Is a pipe?" "Yes." "Is a pump?" "Yes."
Wojciech WegrzynskiChecklist, checklist, checklist.
Nikolin RisiliaCheck, check, check, check, check and nothing else.
Wojciech WegrzynskiAll right. and, uh, how does it look in Nor- Nor- Macedonia?
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevSo generally after finishing the whole building, there is a two type of technical acceptance it's called. Okay. One is for a B type of buildings, which are hotels, shopping malls, uh, regular type of buildings every day. And other type is a governmental building, uh, hospitals, or public building which are with a big, amount of people or are re-related to the, to the government. So in the first type of building, which is B type of building, uh, the acceptance, it's internal, that's called. So the company who is, supervisor, uh, the contractor and the investor making together, checking the detailed project design and signing together that all the papers are according to it and there is no changing dur-during the design. And this kind of, um, statement or document they're submitting to the municipality. The second thing, it's when the government enters in the building, that is the A category, which is, um, high level priority. Then the government have their uh, people who are, from different departments, like who have inside architects, independent body, and they're coming on site and checking everything, papers and on site visit.
Wojciech WegrzynskiOkay.
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevYeah. And that's how you get at the end the permit. Uh, I want to refer also related to new bylaws in, in the country and, uh, recalling standards. So when you're writing a bylaw, what is important? The state of the sta- of, of the country. If your country have good fire brigade, what is the situation with your fire brigade? How much equipment they have? What is the urban situation? So what are the w- um, wide of the streets? What is the height of the buildings? That's how you are making the bylaw and implementing the standards because if you're only translating the stan-standard from some foreign country, that is not the same situation as yours. Mm-hmm. So you need to tickle especially those sensitive elements who are really important related to how much, uh, secure or, fire protected need to be the buildings. Because if you have good fire brigade and can reach 23 meters with ladders and save people, you maybe you don't need sprinkler. But if you have a fire brigade with 10 meters ladder and then do-don't have a rescue team enough to save the people, then you need some kind of active, uh, system who can save those people- Yeah and save lives.
Wojciech WegrzynskiYou want to answer?
Nikolin RisiliaIt's, uh, the thing that, I've said, uh, often that, it's like something, uh, that we work separated by firefighters
Wojciech WegrzynskiMm.
Nikolin RisiliaEverybody's doing something. but, to do this thing in your own is not right.
Wojciech WegrzynskiMm.
Nikolin RisiliaYou have to do together with, uh, firefighters and to, and to discuss with them what is the best for the country. Mm. Or the cities ha- have difference- But, uh- traffic, et cetera
Wojciech Wegrzynskibut the firefighters, do they have a formal take on the projects related to fire safety or y- or you just do this-
Nikolin RisiliaThey
Wojciech Wegrzynskihave because it's the right thing to do?
Nikolin RisiliaYou have to send the project to them.
Wojciech WegrzynskiAh, okay. So they have
Nikolin Risiliaa- At us, yes. Yeah. You can... You send the project to us, and after that you get the permission. Okay. And they come after s- uh, general supervision engineering come to the, uh, to the building and makes everything, construction, fire, et cetera, that is okay. Comes the, uh, the brigade, representative from brigade, and say that the system is, is functional or not. But in general, they just see the system. Mm.
Wojciech WegrzynskiJust check. Just checking.
Nikolin RisiliaBecause they don't have staff, qualified staff to understand what is the system. Now I'm not talking here for pressurization or smoke evacuation. That is a big issue. I'm talking about simple, uh, sprinkler hydrants. At least you have to check even the hydrant have the flow that- Mm or the pressure. But nobody check this. So that is something that, uh, is in general everything is done, if you see, and you have check, check, check, check, check. But you professionally, technically, you are not sure what you have.
Wojciech WegrzynskiI, I think that's, uh, the reason why in Poland it's a little bit different. Maybe actually that's the thing we started with, which is education. Because as I said, every fire officer in Poland is a fire safety engineer. So actually the firefighters have a very strong position on the commissioning. So during the design stage, it is the certified, the higher level fire expert that, uh, writes the, the, the, the projects and that person is kind of a representative of the fire brigade in a way on the project. And that person is the one who is in power. But when you want to open the building, you invite the firefighters to do the technical commissioning and because they are fire safety engineers, uh, a concept of smoke extraction, a concept of sprinkler, a concept of, uh, compartmentation, uh, the, the classes, structural fire resistance, they understand it because they went through a professional education in that direction. Therefore, it means the commissioning process Is sometime, sometimes it could be, uh, checking the boxes. Depends on the building, depends on the- Yes location. Of course, it's, it's, it's, it's var- But in, in principle, you're dealing with people who are supposed to understand the technicalities of what they're checking, and they are also, like, cross-referencing it to the, um, uh, design period material. So if in design it said you had two hours wall and you have one hour wall, that's not gonna be allowed. And, and one thing that I think is very important in Poland, there were cases where major buildings were not opened because of the fire brigade complaints. We had that on a metro line. We- they didn't allow to open the metro line for months becau- until stuff was fixed. We had that on Warsaw Airport. It was, uh, not opened for months before they fixed the s- voice alarm system. We had that on a tunnel, the tunnels that we were involved. A lot... Like, they are very strong in their opinions, and they have actually power to stop, which means people actually followed. I think this enforcement element is something that really pushes people towards, being in compliance with fire safety- Yes rather than just, you know, having a tick box and maybe passing through.
Firefighters Left Out Of Planning
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevSo, the firefighters I think are the people who always need to be asked because they are the risking their lives in the end. And how is in our country, they're put it on site, and they complained few times. We have a seminar, 2025, related to PV panels and roofs.
Wojciech WegrzynskiB- but they But this is by, being nice or this is required? No, th- this is just because you invite them, not because they have a formal say.
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevNo, no, no. They are complaining that they are put it on site. Like- Ah, on the si- Yeah Oh, right. I'm sorry, sorry. I mis- On the site. No, they are, they are not on the table-
Wojciech WegrzynskiOkay
Tatjana Vasiljevic Vladevwith everybody else. They are- That sucks So the, the pr- project is finished. Everything gets finished. They're n- even, uh, never called on site when the project is accepted, finished, done, and in usage. So they don't know the building at all. So we're sometimes recommending the investor to invite them politely so they can see in what condition is the building, what kind of system they have, and only a small introduction. Where is the entrance, where are the main the evacuation, how it's planned. Uh, we have, uh, one seminar, 2025, in wha- in which we, called the fire brigades to be present, and the topic was PV panels at the roof. And we give them space to talk about it or, to say what they need to say. And they tell everybody, How you ex- what is your expectation?" And it was, "Okay, we will install PV panels. There is no regulation, and someone from the fire brigade comes in case of fire and starts suppressing it." And they told them, the fire brigade told them, "No, that's totally wrong because we don't have any kind of training, and I cannot risk any manpower to go upstairs and risk their life because we have lack of training, maybe equipment. We don't know how to react in this situation." So the firefighters in our country, I need to say this, are the last people who are consulted about anything. Mm. So they're only there when there is emergency to blame them. Um, Skopje, it's, uh, the, the main city of North Macedonia. There is a in good condition the fire brigades with, trucks, hoses, and whatever it, uh, needed equipment. But the rest of the country, it's really on the, um, a really bad condition.
Nikolin RisiliaI think this is the same situation to us. Uh, somehow, in difference where Scopia, Tirana is, uh, every day you find a new road and maybe even the firefighter doesn't know that he's opened a new road in Tirana.
Wojciech WegrzynskiMm.
Nikolin RisiliaBecause Tirana is in a rapid urban growth every day and, what is, the big problem that I see is the future with, uh, very high-rise building. we don't even have a register of the buildings in the country.
Wojciech WegrzynskiMm.
Nikolin RisiliaAnd, to see what will be the Tirana after 10 years, you may be you can have 50, I don't know, or you have a 70 high-rise, uh, skyscrapers all around and big public, uh, buildings. Then I'm not sure that firefighters have a idea of the, of the drawings, layouts, how they are and they have checked properly how they can intervene in a case of a fire and this is a big problem.
Wojciech WegrzynskiI, I also think that, mm, educating them in terms of how modern fire safety, concepts work, again coming back to my experience with my, uh, officers being, uh, fire safety engineers, it's very easy because they know that. But even the concept of pressurized staircase, you know, Someone needs to understand what is happening around- Yes to not mess with the system because if you leave few doors open you're gonna ruin the pressurization concept and lose all the benefit you have with it and you have to be aware of how it works. But for it to work you also have to have a ra- razor so they don't have to take hose through the staircase with them and if you have a razor they have to be trusting the razor that it's gonna give them water. That
Nikolin Risiliais the point.
Wojciech WegrzynskiYou know? And, and-
Nikolin RisiliaNot only a pipe.
Wojciech WegrzynskiNot... Yeah. And, and, you know, i- i- if they don't understand, uh, what are the technical concepts behind, what are the maintenance and checks every year on the system to keep it functional, if they have a choice, do I risk and go on the 10th floor and use the razor or I just take the hoses with me as I'm going up? They're probably gonna waste 10 minutes, take the hoses with them- because th- they don't trust the technical solution that was put there in the first place by the engineer. So without this education of the environment around you, you may be fire engineering in a parallel universe of where the fire is gonna happen, you know?
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevTotally agree. So education is crucial. The firefighters must be involved much more in the project. They need to be, involved in, in the moment when the building gets accepted, so they need to know how to act in case of emergency because a blank box in front of you in case when you have a fire emergency and everybody's under pressure, it's a big thing.
Nikolin RisiliaI have to add some- something about that. Uh, as, uh, we talk even me, even Tatiana, and I think in other countries even I know Kosovo, for example, Tatiana knows as well, uh, even Montenegro and Bosnia is the same situation, roughly. Idea is that, we are small countries.
Wojciech WegrzynskiMm.
Nikolin RisiliaAnd to be-- to make big steps, uh, Poland is a big country, have a lot of university academics, even you have a training for them. And for us to think about to, to make all this, strategy and to have this institution is a big issue- Mm and takes a lot of years. The only way to start this is to, to have a common effort with other countries that you are nearby, and we can start with simple things. Even with small trainings for the firefighters. Mm-hmm. With small trainings, but in common even for designers or, fire expert that works in this industry, and this needs to be very fast and not to wait for, uh, two years or three years. And those curricula, academic, et cetera, or s-summer school, whatever called, maybe are things that needs time to do But we need some efforts and fast. SFP could help a lot about experience because to have experience when you think about a plan is very important, as you said. Mm. Because you can translate British standard, but you translate only some parts, and you leave some important parts. Oh. And the re-related document doesn't appear anywhere.
Wojciech WegrzynskiYeah.
Nikolin RisiliaAnd somebody that have ethic, is professional, is fair, he found out that are some related document. Somebody that said, "This is all my law. I can follow up." It just said a sprinkler. I have a sprinkler. Yes, yes. No problem, we can put sprinkler. So the difference is very big on that. So that to achieve something, I think that SFP could do a lot of things in, in Balkan region even, uh, more than in Europe. The reason are very few, firefighters association or let's say even the workshop or seminars in round so that, as, uh, Tatiana shows with their conference in, uh, two years before and with mine in Sep- in September, had a very huge attendance. People that ask for information, but nobody forced them to learn something.
SFPE Chapters As A Fast Fix
Wojciech Wegrzynskith-this is, like, exactly what I-- where I wanted to go at the end of this interview because, uh, you are sitting here with me because you are actually taking steps. Like, you both have, formed the chapters of SFP in your countries. You work to unify the people to, um, spread good, uh, engineering practices in your communities to understand where the practices came from and the context. I think these are brilliant, uh, first steps, and I can only congratulate. But you've also, successfully organized quite huge conferences. Tatjana, you held yours a year ago. I, I had s- I heard so many good things about the, the, the conference. And Nicolin, you've held, held your just a few months ago in, in, in September. I've also heard amazing feedback from my colleagues who have attended. Big, large international events, uh, in your countries and, uh, I, I think that's also a way to mix your own environment with some, more matured players, let's, let's call them, in the game. People who, been doing that for 40 years, what you're trying to do right now, establishing systems and, and relationships and everything. I, I, I hope you g- you guys are continuing. I know, I know you are organizing conference next year. We can plug it in.
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevYeah, yeah. 12th and 13 May 2027 in Hilton DoubleTree will be the next conference. Uh, we already have 16 lineup speakers, so will be something, uh, big. Uh, related to why we organize conference or why we s- I step up first, uh, as in this region to organize something because everything was happening in the West. Yes. And companies, not all the companies have the opportunity to send their engineers around, or engineer by themselves cannot pay all those, costs there. It's not only the ticket, it's accommodation- Yeah, yeah, yeah travels- Travel, of course. Yeah uh, out of work and so on. I, I
Wojciech Wegrzynskiknow the pain very well. Yeah. It was the same for us.
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevYeah, and that's why we, we realized that the re- the Balkan region needs to figure out something that we can bring the experts. Especially, there is a psychological thing related to the people. When you are talking about something that is good, or it's a best practice, or it's need to be done like it is because there is a science behind it, it's really hard to understand you. But if you bring someone from outside and tell the same information as you, everybody will hear it. And that's the thing. I don't know. That's the Balkan. I think that it's the Balkan. I'm talking for my country, but I think pretty much it's totally the same. And bringing outside people who o- Because also in, in North Macedonia, there is from, for example, from the faculties, there is experienced people related to fire. They're giving a lecture a lot of another re- universities- Mm or they're part of some project internationally. But foreigner expertise always it's more appreciated than the one that comes from locals.
Wojciech WegrzynskiYeah. It's, it's all... I, I, I can tell you, we, we had a similar thing, maybe not through SFPE because that was way before Polish SFPE chapter has formed. But, uh, we always have these conferences in, uh, in spring and autumn in Zakopane, which is a mountain town in Poland. I know a lot of people hearing that are smiling i- in, in the listenership. Uh, Zakopane always has some foreign speakers, and they try to bring big names to Zakopane and, and, uh, tho- those people are, handled very well by the locals, uh, cherished as, as our foreign speakers. And they usually have great talks that resonate with the Polish... And I, tell you I think 2008 or 2009 we had Charlie Fleischmann who was talking about performance-based design and year or two years later I have performance-based design in my smoke control. I'm seriously- Yeah connecting, uh- Yeah his presence in, in Zakopane with the fact that the law has shifted. Maybe- Yeah I'm misaligning- Yes but I'm sure there wasn't a, a Fleischmann effect on that. So, uh, I, I think it's great to, to have those people- Yeah visit you and help.
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevYeah, that's the thing. Uh, My point is not with the conference, the, the people to maybe learn detailed design or have a training. To have the information that somewhere someone have realized something that can help them during the project design. And open the
Wojciech Wegrzynskidoor.
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevOpen the door.
Wojciech WegrzynskiYeah.
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevThat's the thing and they can contact them or contact me or contact another expert and if you raise this issue, okay, I have information that someone already solved this and I will ask for the right approach. That's the thing with the conference. It's not that it's a training. Training is totally different thing. Yes. This is only informative that something is happening and what is new, which is really important in the, um, fire industry, not only in the active area. It's pretty new with the materials.
Wojciech WegrzynskiBut the, the thing in terms of trainings there's a lot of online resources and if s- Yes, agreed today if someone wants knowledge they'll find knowledge. Yeah. But as you said, to be aware that solutions exist and they are just routinely applied somewhere and it's a good practice in, in, in one place is good to study that. Nikolin, for you the recent conference like, uh, does it resonate with your people in Albania? Does, does it open the doors for you? Will you continue with tho- those efforts?
Nikolin RisiliaYes, for sure. Uh, I've started this, uh, five years before. Uh, but, uh, b- has been not, uh, easy to start and to understand. People doesn't want to, to make some voluntary job- Hm in Albania due to the, uh, what we remember from communism. So voluntary is something- that nobody believes anymore. But in a, in other hand, uh, I see that, uh, something that is missing in country is fire. Even other engineering a problem, but fire engineering is something that is, uh, like a profession doesn't have real rules. And in other hand most of the people doesn't understand the importance of something that you cannot prove every day. Fire is not something you can, you can test it.
Wojciech WegrzynskiMm.
Nikolin RisiliaBecause you like to test it. You have something you have to think very good and to be very careful. But with this conference. for me it was something very challenging for people to come- Mm because I believe that 30, 40 people will be interested to come to your conference for fire because nobody, uh, makes them to come. But The first day were, were more than 300 people.
Wojciech WegrzynskiThat
Nikolin Risiliawas- And a lot of architects, because to be honest, we have d- done... In three years, we have done some workshops, important workshops, uh, with architects and with engineers from Albania, from Kosovo, even from North Macedonia have came. In the one university that we have a agreement, like Barleti is a private university in Tirana, we have agreement with them to, to make some-- to use the logistic for those, uh, workshops. So that, uh, my idea now is that, uh, to go further, further than conference workshops, et cetera, to go to real trainings. And what I'm discussing even with, with Tatjana and, uh, some other guys during those days is if we can find a, a common platform, we can start to make real training for countries and for this to make for Kosovo, Albania, Bosnia, Montenegro, North Macedonia, people that need to learn and to grow up in this industry that is not, uh... If you learn to, to do a good engineer or good expert on fire, you can work everywhere, not only in Albania or North Macedonia. Is the same. You are ta- talking about engineering and fire. So that, uh, maybe this is the future that I think that is the most, important and, most necessary for everybody that is really serious and professional.
Wojciech WegrzynskiFantastic. I, I think it's, it's, it's really interesting perspective you have. You're on a good way to succeed, and it, it's not just Balkans. You know, Paul in Portugal is doing a lot of great efforts to educate, people and a lot of a lot of events in there. We're trying our stuff in Poland. Everyone is struggling like that. And even in, in the UK, in the US, I assure you, even though they have a system, they're, they, they all the time discuss about reinventing the system because perhaps it's not the most, uh, perfect one, and there's always chance to improve. Uh, you guys discover it from kind of a blank page because you, you, you fill it up, which is, uh, in some cases easier than having, uh, a system originating from '80s, '90s that existed already. Perhaps it's easier, perhaps it's harder. I, I don't know. But I, I think the struggle is global. You're, you're not the only ones, and, and we need to help each other. That's the point of, of- Yes SF Europe, and that's the point of, of, of us sitting down here.
Europe’s Fire Education Bottleneck
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevYeah. I need to mention that it's really, uh, necessary Europe to raise education more in this field because when you compare to UK or United States, there is a full department educating about fire from the basics till the performance based, which over here nowadays there are few university that can cover this Lund?
Wojciech WegrzynskiYeah, there's L- Lund, Ghent, Edinburgh.
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevBut they are full capacity or they're only civil? They have also mechanical or-
Wojciech WegrzynskiThey... Depends on the, on the, in the, on the university. The, uh, Borzano. The, the, the ETH now has a, a fire course. I think Catalonia has a fire course. There's, there's l- l- lot of universities that do that, uh, as a specifics fire protection engineering courses. But my, my worry is that I talk with a lot of people from different parts of the world, numbers of students are declining. Uh, it is more and more economically difficult to sustain this complex, uh, you know... Because fire engineering is a complex discipline, and it's very costly to- Yeah to run this. It's very huge program. So e- everyone is struggling, actually. And then it stresses me out because if our biggest worry is education and we struggle to have what we already have, we worry about those, those departments, we're not in a, in, in a, in a safe spot and, and what we would need is to have more and more. But how do you fill them with students? How do you make sure that people go through those courses? It's... That's a, that's a huge challenge as well.
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevYeah. Yeah, that, that, that's, that's a huge challenge. But again, all those courses are master degree. I think only one university have a bachelor degree of fire engineering.
Wojciech WegrzynskiOh, in Poland, in Poland we have bachelor as well.
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevIn Poland, I don't know if it's another one. Uh, uh, Lund, Ghent.
Wojciech WegrzynskiPossibly. I, um-
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevMaybe one of, of, or two. So I know that in the Balkan region, only Slovenia have some kind of department which is leading for the fire engineering and most of it in the structural way.
Wojciech WegrzynskiMm-hmm.
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevSo related to mechanical and, uh, the way of electrical or whatever it is, materials, architectural planning, there is no,
Wojciech WegrzynskiWell, anyway, uh- Yeah let's close on with some optimist thoughts. I, I hope, uh, we are all on a good pathway, great pathways with our countries to, to have better and better fire safety engineering. There's a lot of work and to be done, and there's a lot of projects to be, uh, delivered, and I can only congratulate you becoming, uh, the leaders in your own countries and, uh, you know, becoming part of the SFP Europe family. We're extremely pleased to, to have you and see SFP Europe grow and thrive. And, uh, yeah, huge thanks for sharing your struggles with, with me and the listeners of the Fire Science Show.
Nikolin RisiliaYeah, I have to add something about SFP. Have been something that in five or six years that I'm active with SFP, have been a very good place to, to learn and to meet people, that, uh, not only you make friends, but for you it's more easy to understand which are next steps because you have some people that, tell you something, their experience, uh, their know-how, et cetera. So that is something that I'm very grateful, honestly. Thank you. Thank you for- And thank you for invitation.
Tatjana Vasiljevic VladevSo I think SFP is a really great platform. You can find the right people on the right place. I, I hope that our, uh, chapter will grow and have a lot of members, and the next conferences will be a lot of people in our, from our country. And always it's better when you're discussing engineer to engineer where it's, there is a knowledge ment in between.
Wojciech WegrzynskiThank you. Thank you very much. And, uh, let's close on that.
Final Takeaways And Thanks
Wojciech WegrzynskiAnd that's it. Thank you for listening. SFP Europe is truly a wealth of knowledge, wealth of people, wealth of personalities and absolute treasure trove of experiences. You would not think that, uh, Albania is perhaps one of the most exciting markets for fire safety engineering and construction overall, and yet, uh, they are and, uh, they are seeking for knowledge, seeking for solutions because they know that the scale of investments happening in their country is something that's not possible to manage with the current existing approaches. North Macedonia, same case. Poland, it was exactly same maybe 10 years ago. It's still quite a booming market and quite a hot economy with a lot of projects, perhaps bigger appetite for performance-based engineering and a different education situation. But still, we are kind of the same. And, you know, markets like this emerge everywhere, and fire safety engineering has to be applied all across the globe. Therefore, I think it's extremely valuable to exchange those, uh, opinions and ideas and, you know, experiences with, with how do you actually make buildings fire safe in different parts of the world. I don't think you could hear such a conversation elsewhere. Therefore, I am super happy to be bringing this niche to the Fire Science Show, and really happy because those are my friends and, uh, they've done great work, uh, establishing their own chapters at SFP, building them up, uh, joining SFP Europe. They're very active being there at the table where we discuss things. We just met literally in person in Venice during SFP General Assembly meeting. Therefore, I had a really good access, uh to them and I'm really happy I did this interview. Also, props to Grunde Jomaas, who, kind of brought out the, the idea for, for the, for the topic. Grunde said that this could be an interesting conversation to be held, and indeed it was. So thanks, Grunde, for fostering great ideas in the world of, fire podcasting that cheers mate. Um, and thanks to you for being here with us. I hope, uh, this was at least interesting to you and, and perhaps, uh, it opened, broadened your view on, on how fire safety engineering is practiced worldwide. This would be it for today's episode. Thanks for being here, me with-- in the Fire Science Show, and looking forward to see you here, uh, another time, another week. Cheers. Bye.
Apple Podcasts
Spotify